Agreed. FailedShapeshifter got a way different reaction on here than Sparky got on TV.com, so TV.com-

Hey! We're back off-topic, oops! 8D
Well, as kageri said before, I also wouldn't think Mac is the kind of kid to care about being 'cool', and especially I'm surprised he dropped Bloo just for acting cool and hanging at The Rock... :-/

That's the way I feel about IMDb (or at least the forum aspects of it - aka Bad Memory Central). The troll to regular user ratio there must be higher than anywhere else on the net, and even then the majority of regular users aren't particularly friendly. I dread to think what kind of discussions they have on the Foster's board over there - frankly, I'm afraid to go in. :macwor:

I'm old enough to remember the days when TV.com was still TV Tome, run by the tyrannical J Nestor, the anti-fan fic man. :herriman:

As for Mac, I agree that "Bye Bye Nerdie" certainly showed us a moment of weakness on his part, but I also feel that since he did the right thing in the end and came through for Bloo when he was at his lowest ebb, he can be forgiven. Whatever mistakes he may have made in that episode (as FailedShapeshifter says, Mac is only human) really weren't deserving of the consequences he ultimately had to face. :P

I've yet to see this episode(I'm DL'ing it right now), but I need to say something.

While I dislike that Mac temporarily betrayed his friends trying to "fit in", I don't hold it against him. I too greatly admire his wholesome character and "be yourself" image -- but he's still a kid, he's still developing mentally and emotionally, and he'll inevitably slip up and he WILL make mistakes sometimes. It's unfair to expect him to be a perfect angel all the time, especially with Bloo as his best friend. This wasn't any better or worse than when he selfishly tried to kidnap the IFs in "Adoptcalypse Now".

To me, the important thing is that Mac eventually realized his mistake and made things right once again... something that the others failed to do for him when Madame Foster stole the Europe tickets or hoodwinked him into an embarassing birthday party.

I understand where your coming from, and I agree that it is good to see the more childish side of Mac every once and awhile. I was just dissapointed that he was so quick to denouce his friends, especially after the speach he gave in Go Goo Go8D I dunno, I ethier expected him to hesitate, or just change the subject.......but like it has been said multiple times, he's only human.

It was just that he denied his friends for someone like Jamze:'(

Oh, and I think that they probably would have apologized later.....especially Wilt, ya know the guy can't go two seconds without apologizing :D If they hadn't, Mac would probably still be a bit sore about it......I know I would be!

I agree with you too, and I *like* it when Mac does something less-than-perfect. In fact that was the jist of what I said on TV.com, that what Mac did in this ep was fairly selfish, and that therefore Mac isn't perfect. Lol and that's when they pounced. ;) There are some people out there who like to believe that Mac is 100% perfect in every way. How dull.

As a reply to the guy who said that Dwayne Johnson (God, I hope that's the correct spelling) would verbally abuse Jamez for his xenophobia, I agree. I hear that Dwayne Johnson plays D&D.

Jamez Withazee
 

This has been bugging me. Doesn't Jamez Withazee seem a bit too old to be in elementary school?

It's possible that it's a cross elementary/middle school. Or Jamez is just hyperdeveloped. Or he's been held back a fair few years (which I think someone's suggested earlier on this thread).

I haven't seen the ep in a while, but is it possible he doesn't even attend that school and only hangs out there because his junior-high peers think he's a dork? 8D

I have just watched Bye Bye Nerdy, and I thought it was a decent/OK episode, not a classic, but somehow a little lacking. The ending could have been better (and I agree about jekylljuice about Mac). I've noticed it doesn't have it's own thread, so I thought I'd bump this one.

I liked the joke with his name- like it is cooler to replace 's' with 'z', which was his surname! However, I found him a little one dimensional. However, this could be applied to coolness in general. I disagree with Mac's speech, coolness is superficial, and about wearing the right clothes etc,- being yourself is different. It applies to Jamez. The fact he looked older suggests that he doesn't seem to care about anything, and has lead to him being held back at school.

BTW, what was it Mac was in detention for?